Cal Abrams, outfielder for the Brooklyn Dodgers and other teams
Brad Ausmus, Houston Astros catcher
Morrie Arnovich
Moe Berg, catcher and spy
Ron Blomberg (1948–) Major League's first designated hitter
Lou Boudreau
Ryan Braun, Major League baseball player with the Milwaukee Brewers
Craig Breslow
Andy Cohen (1904-1988) 2nd baseman for the New York Giants (1926, 1928, 1929). Managed one game for 1960 Philadelphia Phillies
Harry Danning
Harry Eisenstadt
Mike Epstein
Harry Feldman
Scott Feldman
Matt Ford
Shawn Green
Sid Gordon, infielder for the New York Yankees
John Grabow
Adam Greenberg (1981–) former outfielder with the Chicago Cubs
Hank Greenberg — AL MVP 1935/1940, HoF
Jason Hirsh
Ken Holtzman, pitched two major league no-hitters. pitched in the '60s and '70s
Joe Horlen
Gabe Kapler, outfielder for the Boston Red Sox
Benny Kauff — "The Ty Cobb of the Feds"
Ian Kinsler
Sandy Koufax — NL MVP 1963, HoF
Alan Levine
Jesse Levis — Catcher with Brewers and Indians in the mid 1990s.
Mike Lieberthal — Lieberthal's father is Jewish, and he is therefore considered Jewish under Reform Judaism, and is also listed as such by the American Jewish Historical Society and others.
Elliott Maddox, Yankees, Mets, Orioles, Senators, Rangers
Jason Marquis, pitcher for the Chicago Cubs
Erskine Mayer
Buddy Myer, infielder for Senators in the '30s and '40s
David Newhan up for debate as he believes in Jesus
Jeff Newman
Barney Pelty
Lefty Phillips, managed the California Angels in late 1960s and early 1970s.
Lipman Pike, major league baseball's first player.
Jake Pitler
Scott Radinsky
Jimmie Reese
Dave Roberts
Al Rosen — AL MVP 1953
Goodwin Rosen, "Goody"
Richie Scheinblum Outfielder for Indians, Senators, Cardinals, Royals, Reds and Angels (1960s and 1970s) Was on the 1972 American League All-Star Team
Scott Schoeneweis
Art Shamsky, outfielder and first baseman in the '60s and '70s with the Reds and Mets.
Larry Sherry, relief pitcher for the Dodgers
Norm Sherry, pitcher, managed the California Angels
Mose Solomon — "The Rabbi of Swat"
Adam Stern
Steve Stone — 1980 AL Cy Young winner
Steve Wapnick
Justin Wayne
Phil Weintraub
Steve Yeager, catcher for the Los Angeles Dodgers
Kevin Youkilis
Eddie Zosky