Question:
Was Mark Mcgwire breaking any MLB rules at the time he was using steroids?
Chad
2010-01-13 14:18:53 UTC
Was Mark Mcgwire breaking any MLB rules at the time he was using steroids?
Fourteen answers:
I play the game
2010-01-13 21:50:36 UTC
I don't consider it to have been against MLB rules. If it was against the law, possibly it wasn't, is that enough to be called a cheater? Would you ban everyone who ever smoked pot? That is against the law. And how long until someone claims that Advil, since it allows a player to play with less pain, to be a PED?
MiZZou_RAH
2010-01-14 08:53:59 UTC
Mark McGwire retired after the 2001 season, there was NO RULE in MLB against using steroids until the 2002 season.



What he was doing wasn't right and "may or may not" have violated some laws, but there was no rule against steroid use in place by MLB during the entirety of McGwire's career..



Someday they make make smoking, drinking and fooling around on your wife against the rules too, you don't get to go back and enforce those rules retroactively either.
viphockey4
2010-01-13 22:31:41 UTC
Technically no player was breaking MLB rules...but they were all doing something far more sinister....they were breaking the law! Using PEDS without a doctors precription is was and will always be against the law. And there is a certain moral standard that was violated....just because the players union was clever enough to keep language out of the players association contracts with MLB doesnt make it right. I believe the problem was far more widespread than Mark McGwire or even the 106 names on "the list" and the steriod era was far longer than the so called 90's doping but I feel sorry for the guys who did things with honesty and integrity. Those guys probably made less money than they could have if they chose to cheat too and some guys maybe never quite made it in the bigs because they had morals (but they still have normal sized balls today).
?
2010-01-14 00:32:18 UTC
Yes. because if what Jose said was true and it is. Mark was hooting up on team property which means he brought drug paraphenalia into the stadium. He also used the team plane to transport those items and substances. people are not bringing this fact up and I think its a shame because all people are concerned about is that he used. They say "well it wasn't against the rules", what would have happened if a reporter caught him shooting steroids in his ***? Would they have said "oh hey sorry man thats cool I know its not gainst the rules carry on", or what would have happened if his bag spilled out after getting of the plane and a cop saw the needles and vials spill out? Would he or she said "oh hey cool man good luck tonight, hit a home run for me? I doubt it. yes he did break the rules because he used an illegal substance on team property and transported over state lines which also by the way is a federal offense. that why Mark won't tell the truth because he would admit to being a felon....SCUMBAG
Fozzy
2010-01-13 22:31:53 UTC
Yes.

In 1971, Commissioner Bowie Kuhn issued a statement that players "must comply with federal and state drug laws." And possession or use of anabolic steroids without a prescription was and still is illegal in this country.

So while there was no agreed upon punishment for violating this rule, the rules actually began then. These are the same rules that allowed for the suspensions of other players for the use of drugs like marijuana or cocaine.

Don't confuse the lack of a set disciplinary policy with the drugs being "legal" in baseball terms..
Chipmaker Authentic
2010-01-13 23:21:43 UTC
A point to add not touched upon yet -- while there is US federal law regarding manufacturing, trafficking,and distributing steroids, it includes only specific substances and formulations. New ones get added continuously, but until a specific formula is defined as a controlled steroid, it is not an illicit material.



So any lawbreaking that McGwire might have been engaging in, would depend upon what he was using.



As an example, for part of the apparent time when Bonds was using "clear" (THG), it had not yet been added to the federal list. It was banned in late 2003.



Sticky point that makes people unhappy, but true nonetheless, from a legal standpoint (United States federal law) anyway. Lynch mobs tend not to be so technical or picky.



Available general version, of Schedule III, which is referenced by the current MLB Joint Drug Agreement as explicitly included above and beyond anything defined in the JDA: http://www.deadiversion.usdoj.gov/schedules/listby_sched/sched3.htm



MLB did have a policy, issued by Commissioner Vincent in 1991, which was not collectively bargained, had no defined procedures for testing, enforcement, or punitive response, and was largely forgotten by everyone in the game until it resurfaced a few years ago. Even Commissioner Selig considers it non-binding, possibly because it is non-functional, it doesn't DO anything. It amounted to little more than a sternly worded warning advisory.
Information Police
2010-01-13 22:35:56 UTC
Yes. There was an executive order by the Commissioner of Major League Baseball, issued in 1991, which banned all use of illegally obtained controlled substances.



The order had no teeth, since there was no program for testing and no agreement with the player's union regarding punishment, but there was a rule.
MJ S
2010-01-13 22:24:43 UTC
None of the substances he used was banned by MBL at the time he was using them. He might have been breaking federal prescription drug laws depending on how he acquired them.
anonymous
2010-01-13 22:27:39 UTC
I don't think HGH was banned by MLB until 2005.
The Jersey Devil
2010-01-13 22:23:07 UTC
Yes, Steroids has been illegal from all sports for many many years now
18 gibbs 20
2010-01-13 23:15:16 UTC
Nope.
ecwcal
2010-01-13 22:22:00 UTC
Yes.
Michael Cole
2010-01-14 00:28:29 UTC
no, because drugs and steriod werent illegal until they started drug testing. so none of his records are tainted
anonymous
2010-01-13 22:48:53 UTC
hahahahah!!! yeh- USING STEROIDS


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...